Sunday, September 13, 2026

The Light in the Forest


Release Date: July 8, 1958

In this movie, a Native American chief makes a peace treaty with the leader of the British/American army (the story takes place before the American Revolution). As part of that treaty, the Native Americans must return any white hostages they have taken. The story focuses on one of these hostages--True Son, whose white name is John Butler. True Son does not remember his former life and considers himself to be a full-blooded Indian. He resents being forced to re-enter the white society.

As he mingles with the community, True Son continues to insist that the Indian way is the better way. He sees white people as greedy, destructive, and violent. However, he meets some people that view Indians the same way. He meets some people he likes, and some people he hates. One person is a girl named Shenandoe, who lost her entire family to a group of Indians who killed and scalped them. True Son tells her he has never seen a child's scalp in his tribe because they do not kill children.

True Son and Shenandoe begin to fall in love, but just as they profess their love for each other, two Indians come to see True Son. One of them, Little Crane, is killed by Shenandoe's uncle Wilsey, the most hateful man in the community. True Son and his cousin return to the tribe, where the Indians decide to avenge the death of Little Crane by getting twenty scalps. They go on the warpath and get fifteen scalps, including those of children. This bothers True Son, who warns some whites of another attack. This leads to True Son being expelled from his tribe.

To me, the message of this movie is spoken by Del Hardy as he takes True Son back to the white community. Hardy tells him that there are good and bad people on both sides. Unfortunately, it seems to be human nature that we only see the bad in other people that are different than us. At first, True Son believes his Indian tribe is completely good and the whites are completely bad. But the longer he stays with the whites, the more good he sees in many of them. There are certainly some bad people mixed with them as well, such as Wilsey. But when True Son learns that his tribe scalped children, he realizes that his tribe isn't all good either.

Throughout the movie, we see both Indians and whites want to take violent action against each other. They seem to think the only way to have peace is to eliminate the opposition. Shenandoe says it best when she tells True Son, "Killing just leads to more killing... it's hating on both sides that just leads to trouble." This is a message that is just as timely in our day as it was back when this movie was made.

James MacArthur plays the role of True Son/John Butler and does a great job selling the conflict his character feels as he is torn between two worlds. He will go on to star in a few other Disney films as well. Fess Parker plays Del Hardy. As in just about every other Disney movie he's in, Parker's character is a person of trust and is someone who commands the audience's respect.

This movie is based on a book by the same name, and it's a good adaptation of the book, although certain parts of the story were changed to give it a "Disney" feel. The acting is well done and the subject matter is on par with similar Disney movies of the era. Most of all, I think it's an important message that society still needs to learn.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Shaggy Dog

Release Date: March 19, 1959 This is a fun movie! Tommy Kirk and Kevin Corcoran are back as "stage brothers" in this fun comedy! K...