Release Date: December 25, 1957
This is a classic movie! When I hear most people talk about this movie, they mainly focus on the sad ending. But there is so much more to the story that deserves discussion. In fact, the ending wouldn't feel sad at all without the rest of the story! I won't deny the ending is sad, but I want to focus on everything that makes this such a great movie!
First of all, I need to address the cast! This movie sees the return of Fess Parker and Jeff York, but this movie also stars Dorothy McGuire, Tommy Kirk, and Kevin Corcoran, who will all go on to star in several other Disney movies. Each actor portrays their role spectacularly well. In other Fess Parker movies, I feel like he carries the weight of the entire movie, but that is not true in this film. Kirk and Corcoran are especially fantastic and it's no surprise that they go on to play brothers in several other Disney films. The fact that McGuire, Kirk, and Corcoran match the presence and endearment of Parker is a testament of their ability and the high quality of this movie.
Even with the strong emotional and dramatic elements of the movie, there is still humor to be found. A lot of humor is introduced through Bud Searcy, played by Jeff York. His character is meant to be the comic relief (although he also introduces the danger of "hydrophobia," or rabies). My favorite humor comes from Arliss, Kevin Corcoran's character. After Travis shoots their cow, who is infected with hydrophobia, Arliss asks why Travis had to do that. Travis respond, "Because she was sick." Atliss then counters with, "Well you were sick too, how come they didn't shoot you?" Comedic moments like these make this a well-rounded movie.
Old Yeller is more than a story about a boy and his dog; it is a coming of age story. The beginning of the movie sees Jim Coates taking leave of his family for several months to sell a herd of cows. Travis, the older son, assumes the responsibility of being man of the house. His father even tells him that if he does a good job, he'll buy Travis a horse. Wanting to prove himself to his pa, Travis becomes mighty protective of the family and their land.
This need to prove himself leads to immediate conflict when a yellow dog chases a rabbit into a plot that Travis is farming, spooking his horse and causing a lot of property damage. Travis is ready to shoot the dog, but his younger brother Arliss immediately claims the dog as his own. Their mother allows Arliss to keep the dog, much to Travis's fury, and he is ready to shoot the dog at the first chance he gets.
Everything changes, however, when "Old Yeller" saves Arliss from a mama bear, something Travis was ready to risk his own life to do. From them on, Travis adopts the dog as his own (although Arliss will always insist it's his dog). As Travis discusses Old Yeller with his mother, we learn that Travis used to have a dog of his own, and he believed him to be the best dog in the world! As Travis grows fond of Old Yeller, it's almost like reliving his boyhood again.
Old Yeller and Travis camp out to chase away raccoons who are stealing their corn, Old Yeller saves Travis from an angry cow, and saves him again from some wild hogs, getting injured himself in the process. In that moment especially, we see Travis as a little boy again, putting his faith in his mother to help Old Yeller get better and make everything alright again.
And so we find Travis, caught in the middle of boyhood and manhood. Travis never neglects his family duties, but the dog serves as the link to his own childhood. The moment when Travis realizes that Old Yeller is sick is a defining moment in the film. To me, it's even sadder than the moment when he actually has to put out his canine friend. After Travis shoots Old Yeller, his mother offers a sad smile. Why a smile? Perhaps to offer comfort to her boy, but he never even sees the smile. To me, it's because she knows in that moment, her son is no longer a boy. He has become a man.
Their father returns to their home the next day and learns the whole story. He goes to find Travis, who has just finished burying Old Yeller. Jim acknowledges that his son has grown into a man by saying, "I'm mighty proud of how my boy stood up to it. I couldn't ask no more of a grown man." Travis isn't sure how to move on and navigate this next stage of life. To this, his father says, "You can't afford to waste the good part frettin' about the bad. That makes it all bad... I'll tell you a trick that's sometimes a big help. If you start looking around for something good to take the place of the bad, as a general rule you can find it."
This movie is heartfelt, it's wholesome, and it's timeless. It has ups and downs with scenes that make you laugh and scenes that wrench your heart. But its overall tone is positive and inspirational. It is everything I would hope for from a classic Disney movie.